The Conveyor Belt: Melvor Idle 2 Shipped Without Its Balance Pass

It launched at $14.99 with the first game's sidebar on by default and the balance pass deliberately held. Plus StarRupture's Custom Game, OSRS unshipping last week's duo change, and Tideward 1.1.5.

Share

The Conveyor

Melvor Idle 2: A RuneScape Adventure opened Steam Early Access on Tuesday, November 17, at $14.99, discounted 10% to $13.49 as I write this, with Games by Malcs developing and Jagex on the Steam page as publisher. It runs on Windows, Mac and Linux. The content that was locked behind the demo's level 60 cap is in: three new skills (Astrology, Herblore and Agility), 1,138 new items, 121 new enemies, 25 collectable pets, four Mastery Guild ranks, and Act 2 of the quest line, which the team says will take you to around level 70 and "a lot longer to complete than the first."

The sentence worth stopping on is not in the content list. It is the heading above it. "We've seen all the feedback relating to various aspects of Balance around the game. For Early Access, we have been very light on balance changes as many of the new Skills and post-level 60 content you find will largely increase power in every single Skill." They touched two things on purpose, early-game gold (jewellery and early wand sale prices up, early Slayer monster payouts up, feathers down from 4 GP to 1) and the negative magic defence that scaled on melee gear. Everything else waits: "Now that we have the full picture, we can make the required changes based on feedback that is still flowing through."

The second decision points the same way. The Legacy Sidebar, the Melvor Idle 1 style list that shows every skill level at a glance, is not an option you can find. It is on by default, and the sequel's own sidebar is the thing you re-enable in Settings. Alongside it: a toggle to skip the tutorial outright, a "Reach Level" stop condition so a skill parks itself at a number you chose, item stats inside equipment tooltips with a loadout comparison you cycle with Tab, and, on Windows, the default renderer swapped from Vulkan to Direct3D 12 because resizing the window was crashing the game. The Early Access roadmap, with rough timings for everything still to come, arrives next week, after launch rather than before it. The store page's own estimate for the full version is 12 to 18 months.

A sequel's launch build usually asserts two things: this is the new interface, and these are the new numbers. This one declined both. The first game's interface is the default and the tuning is openly unfinished, which means the launch is being treated as the measuring instrument rather than the verdict.

That is the right instrument and it is not free. In a genre metered in wall-clock days, the first weeks of play are being spent against numbers the studio has already said will move, and some of those hours will turn out to have been banked at the wrong rate. What makes it defensible is where the admission sits: not in a Discord reply three weeks later, but at the top of the launch patch notes, above the part everybody reads.

The Early Access launch post and full patch notes | Melvor Idle 2 on Steam

Patch Notes Roundup

  • StarRupture, Update 3: Custom Game (November 19): out of the public test branch and live today, three weeks after the branch opened on October 29. Custom Game is a page of switches rather than a difficulty slider: building costs, building stability and power requirements off, crafting and unlocking costs off, a starting corporation level with everything below it unlocked, corporation levelling speed, enemies disabled or made passive, base-attack frequency, enemy health, damage, amount and spawn randomisation, god mode, infinite stamina, survival depletion rate, death penalty, starting skill level, all inventory slots, and fire wave frequency. Some can only be set on a new game, so read before you start one. The update also adds a scrollable multi-row Hotbar for weapons, consumables and buildings, and reworks keybinding, which resets any custom binds you had to default. Update 3 notes
  • Satisfactory, v1.2.5.1 (November 18): a follow-up to the crossplay patch, aimed at the people who could not get a session started. Coffee Stain Studios raised the bandwidth multiplayer can send and made several replication improvements per feature, which should help with failed connections and with timeouts on very large saves. They say it plainly: these "will not fix every single issue with connectivity out there." Dedicated servers are still PC only and still outside crossplay. v1.2.5.1 notes
  • Unnamed Space Idle, 0.90.1.0 (November 19): the eighth patch posted since content update 0.90.0 landed on November 5. This one is housekeeping with one gift: Base 7 gets three extra loadout slots, the warp upgrade tree opens at a sane zoom and stops zooming out forever, alignment upgrades no longer get stuck, and right click or instant mode on Fleet TM nodes stops charging you resources for work already finished. 0.90.1.0 notes

The Idle Corner

Old School RuneScape unshipped a raid change one week after shipping it. Last Friday I wrote up The Fractured Archive's new scale tuning: solo and duo health up 10%, and the unique drop rate turned from a formula into a hard-coded table, 1 in 16 for solo or duo up to 1 in 7.5 for a group of eight. Wednesday's changelog takes the duo half back. Jagex reviewed the data and agreed with the complaints: every other scale got faster on average, "duos got slower by more than we'd anticipated as carefully-tuned setups that used to enable skips at encounters like Archive Guardian, Moia or Ocellus became very difficult (or impossible) to pull off." The 10% is gone. The compensation is a duo unique rate of 1 in 17 instead of 1 in 16, and they say in advance it "might not be popular."

Practice Mode shipped in the same update, a week after being held. Last week's note said the team hit critical bugs in testing and would "need to rewrite large chunks of the Practice Mode," so this is the rewrite arriving. You pick it on the grouping interface, you can enter any room you have already seen in Normal Mode, you unlock the bosses further down by clearing them start to finish inside Practice Mode, and a Skip Phase button drops you at whichever phase is giving you trouble. The supply plan changed on the way: refunding your own consumables had "technical hurdles that are difficult to overcome without high risk," so instead you get the Guthixian Root, a reusable one-slot item that restores 20 health and acts as Stamina, Super Restore, Super Combat, Ranging and Magic potions at once while curing poison and bleed. The line that explains why a practice room was worth rewriting: more than 1 in 4 duo runs ended in disaster last week.

Quest Month's third week put two more surprise quests in without saying what they are, which is the whole premise. The rewards are public: 3 quest points, 10,000 Slayer XP, 10,000 Prayer XP and an untradeable back-slot sack that holds up to 28 bones of any type and stores them automatically as you pick them up, though you can only take them out at a bank. The second quest pays Farming, Cooking and Herblore XP and leaves two permanent effects behind, disease protection on every Farming Guild allotment patch and a 1 in 100 chance of an extra Seed of Growth from seed packs. The update also pushes the game past 350 quest points, which makes room for another Slayer block slot, and Jagex says that one goes to a poll. One week of Quest Month left, and they have already named it: The Graveyard, with a new Agility course.

The November 18 changelog | Old School RuneScape on Steam

Fresh Off the Line

Horizon Idle came out Thursday, November 19, from solo developer haides, at $4.50 discounted 20% to $3.60, Windows only, with a demo if you would rather look first. It is an idle RPG built on skilling and crafting: mine, refine, research and automate from a single ship toward an industrial empire, level skills to 100, build a fleet for auto-battler combat, and Warp to prestige. The store page's own pitch for the loop is "No energy gates, just numbers that climb forever," which is a specific promise and an easy one to check. Horizon Idle on Steam

Factory on a Train landed the same day from solo developer bahrdev, at $3.99 discounted 15% to $3.39, on Windows and Mac. The pitch is deliberately small: "a short and linear factory game, perfect for a Sunday evening." You mine ore, smelt bars and craft goods inside the train's cars, sell them to the crowds along the line, and fight off drones on the way to the end of the track. There is a demo for that one too. Factory on a Train on Steam

The Tideward Dev Log

1.1.5, Lode Heart, is out. Every gathering and making trade now has a mark of its own, a rule you work by that you pick before the round rather than tap during it: Woodcutting splits a log along its grain, Mining follows a lode so every 20th round in a row at one rock lands its ore twice, Fishing has a run once a day for six hours with a 20% chance of a second catch, and Forging's heavy pieces leave offcuts that become arrowtips. Stay on one rock long enough and its lode strikes open a Heart, which makes the next 100 rounds there Heart rounds and lands a gem on every tenth. Combat got Strike and Armor: every weapon and every ammunition strikes with Point, Edge or Heft, every foe wears one of six Armors, the Strike an Armor is weak to hits 15% harder, a resisted one hits 10% softer, and every boss shifts its Armor at half health. Also in: trade regalia, a second outfit for nineteen trades with nineteen new side quests carrying the boots, 47 skilling sound effects, keyboard and controller play with a page to rebind any of it, and Tidings, an Almanac page that keeps your last 200 notices so one you glanced away from is still there.

The two lines I would rather not have written are in the Fixed list. Volley and Ember Volley were hitting for a hundred times what they should, which means the foes that use them have been far harder than designed and are now far gentler. Spiked Armour could reflect an entire health bar in a single hit, and a reflect is now capped at 35% of your maximum Vitality. One change goes the other way on purpose: a death now destroys one worn item instead of sending it to the Bank, drawn from your 14 gear slots, so the more you wear the likelier a loss, and food and potions are never at risk. Separately, 134 names and 955 descriptions were rewritten so the game reads as itself, with no number changed.

That pair of fixes is the part of Melvor Idle 2's note I believe. A balance pass is not mostly a philosophy about power curves. It is finding out that two numbers were wrong by a factor of a hundred and by a whole health bar, and you do not find those by reasoning carefully before launch. You find them because the game is in somebody's hands.

oz, peskycashew, kotori.piyo and fhutow found the Stowage Token that never landed, the missing bronze and iron bars in Standing Orders, the Buy button sitting over the prices and the empty iCloud tab that said nothing about what to do. Thank you.

Tideward is up for pre-order on the App Store for iPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple TV and Apple Vision Pro. Free to download, one $9.99 unlock, launching February 11, 2027. Pre-order it now. On Android, the open beta is live on Google Play. Saves do not carry between Apple and Android.


The Assembly Line is a free twice-weekly newsletter on factory builders and idle games. Read on the web at blog.manugames.com. Brought to you by Manu Games, makers of Tideward, a premium idle RPG for iPhone, iPad & Mac.