Melvor Idle 2 Will Not Wipe Your Save, and That Is the Expensive Part

The alpha saves survive. So do the demo saves. In an idle RPG that is a bigger commitment than anything on the feature list.

Share

The Deep Dive

Melvor Idle 2 goes into Steam Early Access on November 17, under a longer name, Melvor Idle 2: A RuneScape Adventure, with Games by Malcs developing and Jagex on the Steam page as publisher. I covered the deal and the date on Friday. The sentence I want to spend today on is older than both, and almost nobody quoted it.

It sits in the FAQ at the bottom of the September 29 progress update, answering whether a save from the Patreon alpha gets wiped at release. Community manager Althalus, in a post Brendan Malcolm (Malcs to the community) still co-writes: "No, there will be no save wipes. Just like MI1, we will support alpha saves all the way into the future."

Then the demo post on October 19: "Save files will be forward compatible." Then the Early Access announcement on October 29, under the heading "Your Demo saves will transfer to Early Access": "There's no need to do anything on your side." Set that against the Steam store page, where the Early Access questions say the planned content may take "a total of 12-18 months to complete" and the full version will contain "many new Skills, content and mechanics."

Together those make a commitment nobody asked them to put in writing: every save made from the private alpha onward, carried through a year or more of new skills and systems, and out the other side into 1.0. It is the most expensive promise in the announcement cycle, and in this genre the only one that counts.

A no-wipe promise is a schema promise

Save wipes are not laziness. They are the cheapest escape hatch in live development, which is exactly why they get used. A new skill means new fields. A retuned experience curve leaves every existing file holding numbers from the old one. A renamed item leaves a dead reference in somebody's bank, and the bank is the part players screenshot.

Here is the size of the hatch Games by Malcs just welded shut. Early Access adds three skills the demo did not have (Astrology, Herblore, Agility), lifts the level cap from 60 to 99 with content to match, adds four Mastery Guild ranks, and ships Act 2 of the storyline at roughly three times the size of Act 1, in a build carrying over 1,800 items, over 150 monsters and about 25 pets. Each of those is a migration that has to run on a stranger's file, once, correctly, with nobody watching, and leave them standing exactly where they were. Then again next update, for 12 to 18 months, on files created before the demo existed.

It also has to travel: the same announcement points demo players at Melvor Cloud as what they will use "to play the same save on Mobile when it launches," and the September FAQ confirms iOS and Android after Early Access, plus a planned web version. One save, several clients, a moving schema.

An idle save is not a factory save

Wipe a factory game and you lose a base, but you keep the knowledge, and the knowledge was most of the value. The second megabase goes up faster than the first, and plenty of players restart voluntarily just to do it better.

Wipe an idle RPG and you lose calendar. Progress here is metered in real time by design, and Games by Malcs published the exchange rate themselves in the demo post: reaching level 60 in a skill, played optimally, "should take somewhere in the region of 10-12 hours of playtime," with every skill in the demo capped at 60 and only three of the alpha's skills held back. A player who got most of the way through that spent weeks of their actual life on it, in the background, a few minutes at a time.

You can hand back items, levels and currency, and some games do. You cannot hand back October. That is why the same wipe announcement reads as an inconvenience in one genre and a betrayal in the other, and why the save-compatibility policy, not the content list, is the real product spec for an idle game in Early Access.

The bill does not disappear, it moves

A no-wipe promise is not a free gift to players. It moves the bill.

Balance changes now land on live saves. The Early Access post has some already in motion, "small balance adjustments. Specifically targeting making the early game a bit more enjoyable," and names the Next Fest offender out loud: "what's a little overpowered (looking at you giant chicken)." Those retunes get charged to files that banked the old numbers, which is how a long-running idle game accumulates grandfathered advantages, where "when did you start?" changes what an account is worth. The team pays in migration code it can never delete, and in having to be right about numbers earlier than it would like.

Two details say they know. They tell you to keep your own backup in the same breath as the promise: copy the save string from the gear icon on the character select screen into a text file, or lean on the cloud save. A team that means forward compatibility hands you the escape hatch anyway. And the Steam page says "the price will remain the same upon full release," so there is no launch discount to gamble on and no 1.0 price hike to beat. The first game sells for $9.99 and carries a November 18, 2021 release date, which the sequel's Early Access opens one day short of turning five.

The third promise is a user interface

The Next Fest numbers were large for an idle sequel: over 50,000 demo downloads, a peak of more than 7,200 playing at once, a place on Steam's most-popular-demos list, over 1,000 feedback submissions through the in-game form alone. The top request out of all of it was not content. It was the Legacy Sidebar, "by far our most requested feature," described as seeing "your skills and their levels in one place." The most-wanted item from the biggest test this team has ever run was the return of a layout from the first game.

That reads as trivial and is not. An idle RPG gets opened twenty times a day for fifteen seconds, so the interface is the loop, and its shape lives in the player's hands rather than in the file. Shipping that layout before Early Access rather than after is the same promise in a different medium.

What I am taking into my own game

Disclosure, since it belongs here: I build Tideward, an idle RPG for Apple hardware, so Melvor Idle 2 competes with my game for the same evenings. Credit where it is owed anyway. The precedent being invoked here is the first game's, which launched into Early Access on Steam in 2020 by the team's own account, and the sequel's answer to the wipe question is literally "just like MI1."

What I am taking is not the no-wipe policy itself, which plenty of developers would promise and few would survive. It is the order of operations: publish the save policy before anyone demands it, then let it constrain the design. In Tideward every save migrates forward, and 24 hours of offline progression means a change I ship tonight is charged to every file by tomorrow morning. Writing the policy down first is what stops me from shipping the convenient version of a fix at a player's expense.

A studio that puts "no save wipes" in an FAQ nobody was reading is telling you what it will refuse to do when refusing gets expensive. On November 17 it starts paying. If you are in the demo right now, copy your save string into a text file anyway. They told you to, and they are the ones making the promise.

Early Access date and Next Fest roundup | The demo post, with the forward-compatibility note | September progress update, with the save-wipe FAQ | Melvor Idle 2 on Steam

P.S. Tideward is up for pre-order on the App Store for iPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple TV and Apple Vision Pro. Free to download, one $9.99 unlock, launching February 11, 2027. Pre-order it now.


The Assembly Line is a free twice-weekly newsletter on factory builders and idle games. Read on the web at blog.manugames.com. Brought to you by Manu Games, makers of Tideward, a premium idle RPG for iPhone, iPad & Mac.